Plans have been announced for Leigh Academies Trust to merge with (take over) the struggling Brook Learning Trust. I have regularly looked at the failures of the three Brook schools for too many years: Ebbsfleet Academy; Hayesbrook Academy in Tonbridge; and High Weald Academy in Cranbrook. Although I have doubts about such large Trusts, the children attending these schools and those who will follow them would surely have a much better future under Leigh Academies Trust.
I look in some detail below at the many challenges facing Leigh if they follow this takeover through, but this is a very thorough and professional organisation and its leaders will surely have carried out due diligence and know the size of the task before going ahead.
Assuming this takeover goes through, the Leigh Academy Trust will be running 15 secondary schools (with the opening of the new Leigh Academy Rainham in September), 15 primary schools and two Special Schools. These are mainly in Dartford, Maidstone, Medway and the Weald of Kent around Hub schools, regularly being allocated new Free Schools as they have come on stream, and other existing schools through Conversion or Sponsorship, as set out in the table below.
In 2018 Leigh Academies Trust merged with (took over) the failed Williamson Trust in Medway, all traces of which now appear to have vanished. At that point, it comprised the prestigious Sir Joseph Williamson's Mathematical School, the struggling all through Hundred of Hoo Academy and three primary schools, having had the failed Elaine Primary taken from it. I anticipate a similar fate will await the Brook Trust which will itself soon be forgotten, assuming this takeover happens.
Current and Pending Leigh Trust Academies | ||||||||
Secondary Academies |
| Primary Academies | ||||||
Leigh | 2007 | Sp | K | Hartley | 2013 | Con | K | |
Longfield | 2008 | Sp | K | Dartford | 2014 | Con | K | |
Wilmington | 2010 | Sp | K | Oaks | 2015 | Tr 1* | K | |
Leigh UTC | 2014 | Free | K | Tree Tops | 2015 | Tr 1* | K | |
2014 | Con | G | Molehill | 2015 | Tr 1* | K | ||
Mascalls | 2015 | Tr 2* | K | Langley Park | 2016 | Free | K | |
Strood | 2019 | Tr 3* | M | Eastcote | 2016 | Con | B | |
Halley | 2018 | Tr | G | Cherry Orchard | 2017 | Free | K | |
Leigh Blackheath | 2018 | Free | B | Horsmonden | 2018 | Con | K | |
Hundred of Hoo | 2019 | Tr 3* | M | Paddock Wood | 2018 | Con | K | |
2019 | Tr 3* | M | 2019 | Tr 3* | M | |||
Ebbsfleet | 2021 | Tr 4* | K | High Halstow | 2019 | Tr 3* | M | |
Hayesbrook | 2021 | Tr 4* | K | Stoke | 2019 | Tr 3* | M | |
High Weald | 2021 | Tr 4* | K | Marden | 2020 | Con | K | |
Leigh Rainham | 2021 | Free | M | Bearsted | 2020 | Free | K | |
Special Academies | ||||||||
Milestone | 2012 | Sp | K | |||||
Snowfields | 2020 | Free | K |
Notes: Most schools named also have 'Academy' or 'Primary Academy', with some occasional 'School' as the finish to their title apart from Leigh UTC and Sir Joseph Williamson's Mathematical School, colloquially known as 'the Math'.
*1 Transferred from Academies Enterprise Trust
* 2 Joined from being a Single Academy Trust
* 3 Transferred from The Williamson Trust
* 4 Transferring from Brook Learning Trust if approved
Abbreviations: K=Kent; M=Medway; B = Bexley; G=Greenwich; Con = conversion from maintained school; Tr =Transfer or Re-Broker form another Trust
A number of links to articles on the website are included in the table, but many others will follow from an entry in my search engine (above).
Performance of Brook Learning Trust Schools | |||||
PAN | % Year 7 Vacancies | LAAs | GCSE Progress 8 (out of 101) 2019 | ||
Ebbsfleet | 150 | 45% | 31 | 65th | BA |
Hayesbrook | 151 | 52% | 56 | 93rd | WBA |
High Weald | 150 | 59% | 32 | 91st | WBA |
In my previous article I wrote about the financial difficulties of the Trust, honestly reported in its Annual Report, brought about by falling rolls in all three schools. The 2019-20 Report notes: As a Trust operating three non-selective schools in a highly selective system, pupil numbers can be volatile and subject to risk, particularly when neighbouring schools exercise their freedom to increase their intake in response to parental demand. All three Academies face challenges in this area, but most acutely at the High Weald Academy which has experienced falling rolls in recent years, posing a challenge in terms of setting a balanced budget. The Trust has worked closely with the ESFA and the Kent School Funding Forum, securing additional funds to balance the budget in 2020/21. The Trust continues to work closely with the DfE and the ESFA to ensure the long term viability of its academies.
To be precise, the problem is the complete failure of all three schools to attract pupils, as evidenced not only by the high vacancy rates, but by the high number of LAAs in each school, showing that they are all having to take in high numbers of pupils who simply don’t want to be there. This is not a function of the selective system as claimed. High Weald Academy is now dependent on additional subsidies from government and Kent County Council (at the expense of county maintained schools) to survive, although academies are supposed to be self-sufficient across the Trusts.
In spite of its poor performance of its three schools, the 2019-20 accounts record that three employees of the Trust were paid an annual salary of £100,000 to £120,000 during the year.
An observation: Whilst Hayesbrook is a boys' school with a somewhat macho reputation, the other two academies are mixed. It is therefore surprising that in the five picture strips heading the sections of the Trust website, 33 boys are to be seen, as against just six girls. On another page, the strip still features the notorious previous Principal of Ebbsfleet Academy, who left nearly two years ago.
Senior staff turnover continues at a rate, the Executive Principal appointed two years ago has moved on, Assistant Principals come and go, five heads in seven years - the latest taking up a new post elsewhere in September, the Trust Head of Education two years ago, then became Interim CEO and is now Interim Executive Head of High Weald.
Whilst not directly relevant, the 2019-20 accounts confirm that the PFI loan taken out to build Ebbsfleet Academy, is fully funded by KCC.